The print-on-demand industry is experiencing explosive growth, with the global market projected to reach $103 billion by 2034. As more creators and entrepreneurs jump into this space, one question keeps coming up: should you choose Teespring (now Spring) or Printful for your print-on-demand business?
This comprehensive comparison examines both platforms across pricing, product quality, customer service, and business reliability. We'll also explore the best alternatives to help you make an informed decision for your specific needs.
What you'll learn:
- Real pricing differences between Teespring and Printful
- Quality and reliability comparisons based on user experiences
- Which platform works better for different business models
- Top alternatives if neither platform fits your needs
🏆 QUICK VERDICT
| WINNER | Printful |
|---|---|
| 💰 BEST VALUE | Printful (despite higher upfront cost) |
| 👥 BEST FOR CREATORS | Still Printful |
| ⚠️ AVOID | Spring (unless you enjoy customer service hell) |
| 🎯 RECOMMENDATION | 95% should choose Printful |
Platform Overview & Business Models
What is Teespring (Now Spring)?
Teespring rebranded to Spring in 2021 and was acquired by Amaze Software in 2022. The platform operates as a hybrid marketplace where creators can design and sell custom products while Spring handles production through external partners.
Spring's business model centers on social commerce integration, making it particularly attractive to content creators with established audiences. The platform is free to use, and creators keep 100% of their markup above Spring's base costs.
How Does Teespring Work?
The teespring print on demand process appears straightforward: upload your design, choose products, set your markup, and start selling. Spring handles production, shipping, and customer service while you focus on marketing and promotion.
However, this simplicity comes with significant trade-offs in quality control and business reliability that we'll explore throughout this comparison.
How Does Printful Work?
Printful takes a completely different approach with full vertical integration. Founded in 2013, this company owns and operates 13+ fulfillment centers across four continents, controlling every step from printing to shipping.
Unlike Spring's marketplace model, Printful functions as a fulfillment service that integrates with various e-commerce platforms. While they offer a free plan, their Growth plan ($24.99/month, free after $12,000 in annual sales) provides significant discounts and advanced features.
The Fundamental Difference
Spring prioritizes getting creators started quickly with minimal barriers. Printful prioritizes building sustainable, scalable businesses with reliable operations. This philosophical difference impacts every aspect of their service.
Is Teespring Legit? Trust and Reliability Analysis
Addressing Legitimacy Concerns
Is Teespring legit? Yes, Spring is a legitimate company that won't steal your designs or disappear with your money. However, legitimacy and reliability are two different things.
Teespring Reviews: What Users Report
When examining teespring reviews across independent platforms, a concerning pattern emerges. Trustpilot shows Spring with a 2.6/5 rating, with common complaints including:
- Extended payment delays (3+ months)
- Poor product quality and sizing issues
- Unresponsive customer service
- Orders stuck in production for weeks
Level Up With PrintCube!
Simply use PrintCube for print on demand. Get started for free. No credit card or subscription required.
Sign Me Up!Is Teespring Good for Building a Business?
The answer depends on your definition of "good." For testing design concepts with zero upfront investment, Spring can work. For building a reliable income stream or professional brand, the platform presents significant challenges.
Consider this scenario: You create a viral design that generates 100 orders. With Spring's higher base costs and quality issues, you might face customer complaints, refund requests, and payment delays that could damage your reputation and cash flow.
Products & Quality: A Critical Comparison
Teespring Products and Quality Standards
When evaluating teespring products, transparency becomes a major concern. Spring offers approximately 180 products but won't disclose manufacturer details or material specifications. This lack of transparency makes it difficult to set proper customer expectations.
User reports consistently mention issues with teespring t-shirts and other apparel, including:
- Poor material quality that feels cheap
- Sizing inconsistencies across orders
- Print quality that cracks or fades quickly
- Limited design customization options
Printful's Quality Approach
Printful offers 432+ products with complete transparency about manufacturers and materials. Premium brands like Bella+Canvas, Champion, and Under Armour are clearly labeled with detailed specifications and size charts.
Their quality control system maintains a 0.24% order reshipping rate through rigorous inspection processes and significant investment in printing equipment.
| Quality Factor | Printful | Spring |
|---|---|---|
| Product Transparency | Full manufacturer details | Hidden sources |
| Quality Control | In-house verification | Partner-dependent |
| Reshipping Rate | 0.24% | Not disclosed |
| Design Tools | Advanced suite | Basic functionality |
Pricing & Profit Structure: The Real Cost Analysis
Teespring Pricing vs Printful: The Numbers
Here's where Spring's "free" model reveals its hidden costs:
| Product | Printful Base Cost | Spring Base Cost | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Black T-Shirt | $9.25 | $17.45 | +89% |
| Trucker Hat | $11.45 | $22.60 | +97% |
| Tote Bag | $13.95 | $20.99 | +50% |
| Coffee Mug | $5.95 | $10.99 | +85% |
Profit Margin Impact
Using a $25 t-shirt as an example:
- Printful profit: $25 - $9.25 = $15.75 (63% margin)
- Spring profit: $25 - $17.45 = $7.55 (30% margin)
Spring's higher base costs effectively cut your profit margins in half.
Is Teespring Free? Understanding True Costs
While Spring has no upfront fees or monthly costs, the platform's expenses come through inflated base prices. When combined with quality issues leading to refunds and payment delays affecting cash flow, the "free" platform often costs more than paid alternatives.
Platform Features & Integration Capabilities
Spring's Social Media Strengths
Spring excels in social platform integration, particularly for established content creators. The platform offers seamless connections to:
- YouTube (merchandise shelf for 10k+ subscribers)
- TikTok and Instagram
- Twitch streaming integration
- Discord community features
Printful's Business Ecosystem
Printful provides 23+ integrations covering major e-commerce platforms including Shopify, WooCommerce, Etsy, Amazon, and eBay. This flexibility allows businesses to start on one platform and scale across multiple channels without changing fulfillment partners.
Design and Customization Tools
Spring offers basic design functionality with limited customization options. Printful's Design Maker includes advanced features, extensive font libraries, and access to professional stock imagery.
Making Money: Payout Reality and Payment Systems
How Does Teespring Pay You?
Understanding the teespring payout system reveals significant concerns. Many sellers report payment delays extending 3-4 months, with limited communication about processing timelines. This creates cash flow problems that can severely impact business operations.
How Much Does Teespring Take?
Rather than charging transparent fees, Spring increases base product costs well above market rates. This hidden fee structure often results in lower profitability than platforms with upfront commission charges.
Printful's Payment Reliability
Printful processes payments within 7-14 days of order fulfillment, providing predictable cash flow for business planning and growth.
Best Teespring Alternatives for Different Needs
1. Printful (Recommended for Most Users)
- Lower base costs than Spring
- Superior quality control
- Reliable payment processing
- Comprehensive platform integrations
2. Printify The printify vs teespring comparison shows similar marketplace models, but Printify offers more print partner options and generally better pricing than Spring.
3. Redbubble For artists seeking organic discovery, redbubble vs teespring shows Redbubble's stronger marketplace presence, though profit margins are typically lower.
Other Notable Alternatives to Teespring:
- Fourthwall: Creator-focused platform with strong social integration
- Gooten: Enterprise-level fulfillment capabilities
- Gelato: Global fulfillment network with local production
These alternatives to teespring offer various advantages depending on your specific business model and requirements.
Customer Service: A Critical Business Factor
Spring's Support Challenges
Customer service represents Spring's most significant weakness. With a 2.6/5 Trustpilot rating, common complaints include:
- Response times extending weeks
- Automated replies that don't address specific issues
- No phone support availability
- Limited resolution capabilities for production delays
Printful's Professional Support
Printful maintains 24/7 customer service with rapid response times, knowledgeable staff, and proactive issue resolution. Their 4.6/5 Trustpilot rating from thousands of reviews demonstrates consistent service quality.
Platform Selection Guide
🎯 Choose Spring If You:
- Have an established YouTube audience (10k+ subscribers)
- Want to test print-on-demand with zero upfront investment
- Primarily sell through social media platforms
- Can tolerate quality inconsistencies and payment delays
🎯 Choose Printful If You:
- Want to build a sustainable business
- Value product quality and customer satisfaction
- Need reliable fulfillment and payment processing
- Plan to scale across multiple sales channels
Conclusion: Making the Right Choice
Based on comprehensive analysis of pricing, quality, reliability, and user experiences, Printful emerges as the better choice for most print-on-demand businesses.
While Spring offers easier entry with no upfront costs, the platform's higher base prices, quality issues, payment delays, and poor customer service create significant long-term challenges.
Key Takeaways:
- Spring's "free" model often costs more through hidden expenses
- Printful's higher upfront investment pays off through better margins and reliability
- Quality control significantly impacts customer satisfaction and repeat business
- Reliable payment processing is essential for sustainable business growth
Final Recommendation
For creators serious about building a profitable print-on-demand business, Printful's combination of competitive pricing, quality products, reliable fulfillment, and professional support makes it the clear choice.
Spring might help you get started quickly, but Printful helps you build a business that lasts.
Level Up With PrintCube!
Simply use PrintCube for print on demand. Get started for free. No credit card or subscription required.
Sign Me Up!