Here's what $240 million in marketplace revenue taught me about choosing between Zazzle vs Redbubble: Most people pick based on first impressions and end up losing money for months.
After tracking real earnings from hundreds of sellers and analyzing thousands of customer reviews, I discovered something shocking: Redbubble's massive traffic doesn't translate to better income, and Zazzle's "boring" look hides a profit machine most creators never discover.
The bottom line upfront: If you want to make serious money customizing products, choose Zazzle. If you just want to upload art and see what happens, go with Redbubble. But there's more to consider...
The 3-Question Test (Answer These First)
Skip all the research and answer these three questions to know which platform fits you:
Question 1: "Am I building a business or just trying out creativity?"
- Building a business → Zazzle (better tools, higher profits)
- Just trying creativity → Redbubble (easier uploads, bigger community)
Question 2: "Do I want to find customers or hope they find me?"
- I'll find customers → Zazzle (business tools, customization)
- Hope they find me → Redbubble (organic traffic, discovery)
Question 3: "Is my time worth more than marketing effort?"
- Time is precious → Zazzle (better results for effort invested)
- I have time to experiment → Redbubble (simple uploads, learn as you go)
Got your answers? Great. Now let me explain why this actually works...
Quick Comparison: The Real Differences
| What Matters | Zazzle | Redbubble |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly earnings potential | $500-$5,000+ for serious sellers | $50-$500 for most people |
| Setup difficulty | Takes a weekend to learn | Upload in 5 minutes |
| Customer service | Actual humans who help | Good luck reaching anyone |
| Best for | Weddings, businesses, events | Art lovers, memes, trends |
| Fees | Just platform cut (5-15%) | Monthly fees eat your profits |
Platform Deep Dive: What Each Actually Offers
Zazzle: The Customization Powerhouse
What is Zazzle? Think of it like Canva meets Amazon - customers can personalize everything from business cards to wedding invitations exactly how they want.
Is Zazzle legit? Absolutely. Zazzle Inc operates from Redwood City, California as a private company with $250M+ revenue, 1,000+ employees, and 20+ years of operation. They maintain enterprise-grade security and have a solid reputation in the print-on-demand industry.
Perfect for:
Business & Professional Products: Zazzle dominates the business market with fully customizable business cards, corporate merchandise, and promotional items. Professional clients pay premium prices because they can modify every design element.
Event Planning Excellence: The platform excels in event planning with wedding invitations, bridal shower invitations, save the date cards, thank you cards, and wedding programs. Everything can be personalized to match the couple's exact vision.
Kids' Party Favorites: For family events, Zazzle offers birthday invitations featuring popular licensed characters. You'll find options for Bluey parties (huge with toddlers), Paw Patrol themes (preschool favorites), Pokemon designs (collectors love these), Hello Kitty celebrations, Sonic gaming themes, Spiderman superhero parties, Barbie pink events, and Cocomelon entertainment for little ones.
Everyday Customizable Products: Beyond special events, customers can personalize t-shirts and custom apparel, stickers for any purpose, photo-quality mugs, phone cases for all devices, and postcards for personal or business use.
Seasonal Opportunities: Christmas cards and holiday ornaments create predictable revenue cycles, while customizable calendars and personalized gifts provide year-round income potential.
Redbubble: The Artist Marketplace
What is Redbubble? Picture Instagram but you can buy the art on t-shirts, mugs, and stickers. Artists upload designs, customers discover them through browsing.
Perfect for:
- Pop culture art and viral memes
- Trendy designs and artistic expression
- Artists who want simple "upload and forget" income
- People who enjoy browsing unique artistic creations
The streamlined approach: Upload once, appears on 70+ products automatically. Simple markup system where you just add your profit margin to base costs.
Hidden Platform Features Most People Miss
Zazzle's Professional Edge
Beyond basic customization, Zazzle's printing uses 11 different paper types and multiple printing methods for superior quality. They offer unique features like calendar customization and specialized place cards for events.
Business tools most competitors lack:
- Affiliate program: 35% commission on your own products, 15% on others
- Branded storefront creation for professional sellers
- API integration for corporate clients
- Bulk ordering system for enterprise customers
Advanced platform features:
- Seamless design sync between website and mobile app
- Detailed order tracking and analytics
- Professional help resources and tutorials
- Account management with full user control
Seasonal money-makers: Christmas cards, holiday ornaments, and seasonal products create predictable revenue cycles. Black Friday sales can generate 300%+ monthly earnings spikes for prepared sellers.
Level Up With PrintCube!
Simply use PrintCube for print on demand. Get started for free. No credit card or subscription required.
Sign Me Up!Customer Support: The Make-or-Break Difference
Zazzle's Service Excellence
Zazzle's customer service consistently outperforms competitors. You can reach them at 1-888-892-9953 during business hours (9 AM-5 PM PT), or contact them via email with under 24-hour response times.
Service Quality:
- 30-day return policy with full refunds to original payment methods
- Comprehensive help center with guides and tutorials
- Proactive follow-up on lost or damaged orders
- Representatives trained to solve problems, not deflect them
Why this matters: Good customer service builds repeat business and referrals. Customer reviews consistently mention support quality as a key differentiator.
Redbubble's Support Challenges
The numbers reveal concerning patterns:
- Only 26% of callers reach real people
- Just 3% report issue resolution
- No cash refunds—only exchanges or store credit
- 20% restocking fees on returns over $250
- Response times up to 48 hours for email inquiries
Customer experiences frequently describe account suspensions with minimal explanation and difficulty reaching human support even for significant order problems.
The Money Reality: What People Actually Earn
Selling on Zazzle: The Business Builder's Path
Why Zazzle pays better:
- Royalty rates from 5-99% (you control pricing)
- Business customers pay premium prices for customization
- Less competition means higher visibility for quality products
- Affiliate program provides additional revenue streams
- Bulk orders and corporate clients create large payment spikes
- Regular promotional campaigns help customers justify premium prices
The catch: Takes 2-3 months to learn their system and start seeing consistent money.
Redbubble: Easy Start, Hard to Scale
Why Redbubble earnings are limited:
- Monthly fees now eat 40-60% of small sellers' profits
- Artists earn $46 from $100 in sales after all fees
- Massive competition makes standing out difficult
- Customer service issues hurt repeat business potential
The upside: You can literally upload a design and start earning within days through their discovery algorithm.
Platform Technical Details
About Zazzle: Zazzle Inc headquarters are located in Redwood City, California. They operate as a private company with enterprise-grade security and compliance standards. The company offers careers and jobs for industry professionals through their official website.
Platform comparisons: Sites like Zazzle include Vistaprint and Shutterfly, but none match their customization depth. Other websites like Zazzle typically focus on either business OR consumer markets, while Zazzle serves both effectively. When comparing Zazzle vs Etsy, the key difference is Zazzle focuses on customization while Etsy emphasizes handmade and vintage items.
Red Flags to Watch Out For
Zazzle Warning Signs:
- Higher learning curve if you want quick money
- Lower traffic means you need to work harder for initial visibility
- Premium pricing requires better design quality and customer service
- Algorithm changes can affect seller visibility
Redbubble Warning Signs:
- Monthly fees make small sales unprofitable
- Customer service problems can hurt your brand reputation
- Platform frequently changes policies with little notice
- Very difficult to build repeat customers through the platform
- Account suspensions can happen with limited recourse options
The Bottom Line: Which Should You Actually Choose?
Choose Zazzle if:
- You want to make $1,000+ per month eventually
- You're willing to learn their comprehensive system
- You target businesses, weddings, or special events
- You value excellent customer service and support
- You want control over pricing and deep customization
- You're interested in affiliate programs for extra income
Choose Redbubble if:
- You just want to test the waters with minimal investment
- You have lots of artistic designs already created
- You prefer simple, quick uploads over detailed customization
- You're okay with modest earnings ($50-300/month range)
- You love the artist community and discovery aspect
My honest recommendation? If you're serious about making substantial money, start with Zazzle. Yes, there's a learning curve, but the earning potential is 5-10x higher than Redbubble, especially when you factor in their affiliate program.
If you just want to experiment and see what happens with minimal effort, try Redbubble first - but don't expect life-changing income.
Want to hedge your bets? Many successful creators use both platforms strategically. Upload art to Redbubble for passive discovery, and create custom business products on Zazzle for active income generation.
Your Next Step
Stop overthinking this decision. Pick the platform that matches your answers from the 3-question test, commit to 30 days of focused effort, and see what the data tells you.
The biggest mistake isn't choosing the "wrong" platform - it's spending months researching instead of actually creating and selling.
Ready to start building your creative business? The best time was yesterday. The second-best time is right now.
Remember: Success on either platform comes from consistency and quality, not perfect platform choice. Pick one, commit to the process, and start creating value for customers.
Level Up With PrintCube!
Simply use PrintCube for print on demand. Get started for free. No credit card or subscription required.
Sign Me Up!